Steelers Report Card: @ Browns

Featured image: Caitlyn Epes/Pittsburgh Steelers

Subject: Run defense/gap integrity

Grade: A-

Explanation: The Browns came into this game the #1 ground attack in the NFL. The Steelers limited them to 96 yards and forced them out of the top spot. It was only the second game of the year they were held under 150 rushing yards (they tallied 73 against Arizona in a game without Nick Chubb).

Textbook run fits here on the Browns’ first fourth down attempt. Highsmith and Buggs control the middle of the line; Heyward crashing from the left forces the LT into the path of the pulling guard so he can’t get out in front on Bush. If Chubb finds the edge and it’s up to Joe Haden to bring him down solo with a head of steam, good luck!

Browns’ first failed fourth down conversion

I had to ding them half a grade for allowing one explosive run to Chubb. Watching it live it looked like Buggs was responsible for the gap Chubb cut back through. After they showed this replay I’m not so sure it’s his fault. Chubb dragged Minkah for an additional 10 yards after contact.


Subject: Get them in “third and obvious” situations

Grade: A+

Explanation:

‘Nough said

Subject: Limit Myles Garrett’s downhill opportunities

Grade: B-

Explanation: Limiting the NFL’s leading sack artist to 1 sack and 2 QB hits is a W. Full stop, end of paragraph.

I didn’t love how often they left him one-on-one with rookie LT Dan Moore, most notably the 2-point conversion attempt from the 12. It’s hard to ask a RB to pick Garrett up when he’s in the backfield with a head of steam, but you can get a TE to chip him at the line and force him off-schedule. Garrett is too much man to ISO on any one lineman, especially a rookie, and ESPECIALLY on key snaps.

In my preview this week I wrote about running to his side and throwing swings and screens over his shoulder to get him to waste energy chasing plays. I liked how they used McFarland and the pitch-out; I didn’t like it as much when they did it to Ballage.

Pitch game 💪

Subject: Reinforcements for Najee!

Grade: C+

Explanation: McFarland had 1 rush for 1 yard in his first game of the year coming back from a knee injury. As I said above I liked the “set ‘em up, knock ‘em down” they planned for him. I’m glad they didn’t overload his plate but it’s hard grading him more than an incomplete.

Harris, Snell and Ballage are all power runners; McFarland offers them a different look when the bell cow needs a breather, instead of just a worse version of the same look. Moving forward I’d like McFarland to show he can step up and give the Steelers decent third quarters so Harris is fresh and in position to slam the door shut late.

Preview: Steelers @ Browns

Coming out of the bye the Steelers are in a good place, health-wise. Mike Tomlin said in his Tuesday presser he anticipates availability won’t be an issue for any of his (active) players leading up to Sunday’s road matchup with the Cleveland Browns. TE Eric Ebron had some hamstring tightness that limited his Thursday practice reps, but I don’t see that affecting the two targets he’s likely to see this week.

For the Browns, the exact opposite is true: they had 17 players listed on the initial Wednesday injury report. WR Donovan People-Jones, CB Denzel Ward & DE Jadeveon Clowney didn’t practice at all this week. Their offensive line will likely be missing their starting C JC Tretter, and two of the three tackles on their active roster were limited in practice all week.

Speaking of playing hurt, QB Baker Mayfield has a torn ligament in his non-throwing shoulder and missed their last game, but he’s practicing with the starters this week and wants the green light. WRs Jarvis Landry and Odell Beckham Jr have also been limited. Divisional games at home skew towards the “must-win” end of the spectrum, so you can bet anyone on their side who’s close will want to play.

The guys we know won’t be out there are the 12 (oof) on injured reserve: most notably LB Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, T Chris Hubbard and RB Kareem Hunt. JOK was having a strong rookie campaign; when he was hurt in the fourth quarter of the Cardinals game two weeks ago he led the team in tackles (29) and passes defended (4). Hubbard was the Steelers’ swing tackle a few years back but left for a starting gig with Cleveland. Hunt is…well he’s Ray Rice with a job.

Cleveland boasts the NFL’s best rushing attack: without Hunt they still have an all-pro in the backfield in Nick Chubb. They’re going to need to lean on that ground game with Mayfield and anyone he might throw a pass to being less than 100%. Having said that, Chubb was also limited all week in practice, so it may be another D’Ernest Johnson Day. He looks to build on the coming-out party he showed last week against the Broncos (22 carries, 146 yards).

By yardage, their defense is ranked seventh against the pass and second vs the run. They’re third in sacks, primarily on the strength of their DEs: Myles Garrett leads the NFL with 9.5 and Jadeveon Clowney – despite an inauspicious start to his Browns career⬇️ – has ponied up 3.5.

K Chase McLaughlin served with five different teams his first two seasons in the NFL but has played all seven games for Cleveland this year and appears to be sticking. He’s perfect on XP’s and 10/11 on FG attempts (4/4 from 50+ yards, including a 57-yarder). Don’t feel secure with a late lead less than four points; he could steal one.

Keys to the Game

1) Know your gap and commit to it. The last time we saw the Steelers’ defense they were getting gashed by the Seahawks’ backup running back. Many of those wounds were self-inflicted (overrunning gaps, a Benny Hill mixtape of missed tackles) and that needs to be tidied up. Have I mentioned Cleveland is the best rushing team in the NFL?

2) “Situational Ball” The Browns have allowed the NFL’s fifth-highest third-down conversion rate. Extending drives wears down opposing defenses, takes the crowd out of the game, gives your defense more time to recover on the sideline and chips away at their confidence. Our defense has the ability to stand tall on short fields, but the more tackles you ask them to make the less likely they’ll have success. Steelers/Browns games historically have come down to the possession battle, which also means PH3 could be called upon in a key moment to flip the field. It’s difficult for a punter to win a game, but they sure can lose one.

3) Limit Garrett’s opportunities coming downhill Throw screens and swing passes over Myles Garrett’s shoulder. Make him take redundant steps and waste energy chasing plays. If you want Ben to drop back, chip Garrett with a TE and/or leave the RB in to pass protect; we don’t need to see a ton of 5-man routes because Ben rarely gets that deep into his progression anyway. Nobody else on the Browns’ front really scares you, especially if Clowney can’t go. You can triple-team Myles all day if you want to.

4) Reinforcements for Najee! RB Anthony McFarland was activated this week after spending the first 7 weeks on IR. Backup RBs Benny Snell and Kalen Ballage total 36 yards on 14 attempts. Although the talent levels clearly aren’t even, those three runners represent redundant skill sets. McFarland will provide a legitimate change of pace that hasn’t been there for this team.

The extent to which they’ll employ two-RB sets remains to be seen; before Juju went down for the year it was hard imagining who Matt Canada would take off the field to bring in an extra RB. In 2018 Jaylen Samuels ran the Wildcat to great success against the Patriots, and we haven’t seen the Wildcat since. Offensive schemes like that are entirely match-up contingent, but it may prove to be the secret to unraveling this Browns run defense.

SkyCam: Steelers/Seahawks

On Sundays we learn who won, but it’s not until Tuesday when the All-22 tape is released that we find out why. Each week I’ll be combing through the coach’s film and highlighting some of what we missed from the broadcast tape.

Play #1

Where better to start than the first (defensive) play of the game? Isaiah Buggs faded in this contest and ultimately left due to injury, but he had a strong into here. He’s lined up in the A-gap (between the center and a guard, in this case the left guard).

At the snap the line flows to the left in the direction of the jet sweep action. The center is trying to pull out to get into the hole and lead block, but Buggs gets into his body, gets control of him and slows him down. He carries the center all the way upstream, disengages at will to fill the running lane and he ends up sharing a tackle for loss with Cam Heyward.

Play #2

When tape rolls, Minkah is in single high while Haden and Sutton are shoulder-to-shoulder on the bottom of your screen. At the snap Sutton’s head turns to Haden and you can see him pointing out towards the flat. Haden curls down to #16 in the flat and Sutton starts giving ground. Minkah senses that and assumes Cam will carry the deep route, so he bites on the TE (#81) running a cross. When Sutton also ends up on the same guy at the end of the rep, someone has some ‘splainin’ to do.

By the letter of the law the go route is probably Minkah’s responsibility. It’s important to note the QB’s primary read was to that right side and he had looked away. I’m sure Minkah saw that and figured “there’s no way he’s looking back that way with TJ and Highsmith barking at his heels.” The play doesn’t show up in the box score but you can bet it will be discussed in the film room.

Play #3

Sticking with the theme of Norwood, he’s the only one in the middle of the field here, running with Tyler Lockett (#16). Sutton is up near the line bluffing a blitz, but at the snap he spins off on Metcalf (#14). Metcalf and Lockett are running man coverage-beating rub routes. The goal there is to get Sutton and Norwood to bump into each other as the receivers cross the middle of the field and “rub” one of them off so his guy can get open.

Sutton disrupts Metcalf and affects the geometry of his route. Metcalf tries to break free by going over the top; he’s instinctively trying to create separation instead of doing his job on the play which is to sacrifice himself to create separation for Lockett. The altered route pulls Sutton out the path of Norwood who is in position to make another good stop.

Play #4

Chase Claypool is an insane athlete; there’s a list of considerable length of things he’s better at than most other humans. Run blocking – especially against run-stopping linebackers – is not on that list. Here he’s pulling across the formation as a lead blocker, but he’s got a posse. Freiermuth and Okorafor are also on the move. There are three guys who need to be blocked on that side, and they have three lead blockers.

Freiermuth is going to seal the outside edge by going out and getting the CB on that side. Claypool is supposed to hit the hole hard and hit whoever he sees first even harder. Chase doesn’t do much to slow #56 and Okorafor has to clean up Claypool’s mess. As a result Okorafor can’t climb to the third guy who needs blocked; Jamal Adams comes in free and gets a hard shot in on Najee.

Play #5

It’s been a while (s/o to Stain’d) since Steelers fans saw a QB with this much time to operate. Eugene Smith helped his cause by dancing around back there, but he had 7 seconds before he threw this ball. Now, did the RG get away with a hold on Chris Wormley here? I slowed it down so you can judge for yourself.

The Steelers only brought a four-man rush here, and neither TJ nor Heyward were on the field at the time. Melvin Ingram does a good job holding Smith in the pocket and Highsmith overpowers the LT. Henry Mondeaux was…also there.